When she was 16 years old, Madeline Eloise Gracechurch faced her looming debut of her first London season….and panicked. Eager to escape the demands of society (and desperate to avoid making herself look foolish), Maddie invents a fictional suitor – Captain Logan MacKenzie and begins writing letters to a man that doesn’t exist. So, though, her small, innocuous fib turns into an elaborate lie, one that continues for years, until Maddie pretends to mourn his death. Imagine her surprise, shock and disbelief when one Captain Logan MacKenzie appears on her doorstep many years later, very much alive – and very determined to turn their imagined courtship into a real one.
Like many young girls, I kept a diary when I was in middle and high school. I wrote about my life, my friends, and yes, even my crushes. I recorded all the little details that seemed so incredibly important at the time and which, in retrospect, make me laugh and cringe at my younger self – who apparently spent an inordinate amount of time pondering the trendiness of my fashion choices (it was the 90’s – there was a lot of flannel). Thankfully, though, these diaries remain in my possession, stored away in a box, never to see the light of day. The heroine of When a Scot Ties the Knot, Madeline Eloise Gracechurch, was not so lucky.
For Maddie, her letters to her imaginary suitor become a diary of sorts; she unburdens herself in these letters, writing things she’d never tell anyone else, because she is convinced the letters are going nowhere. For Maddie, the letters to Captain Logan MacKenzie (and all his various nicknames: MacWhimsy, MacFantasy, Imaginary MacFigment, and perhaps most telling, “dear, silent friend”) represent a chance to be completely honest. Naturally, she’s mortified when it turns out Logan is very real, very handsome, and very determined to marry her. When a Scot Ties the Knot (the third book in Tessa Dare’s Castles Ever After series) is wonderfully, romantically typical Dare: funny and sweet, with just the right blend of humour and heart. It presents a new spin on that old adage: be careful what you wish for.
“She felt as though she’d spent her youth stuffing heartfelt wishes into bottles and tossing them into the ocean – and suddenly, years later, they’d all been returned.”
Dare excels at writing unconventional, offbeat heroines who don’t quite fit in, and Maddie is no exception. Painfully shy with a paralysing fear of crowds, Maddie cannot stand to spend much time in society. And while she is a talented artist, she prefers drawing the natural world (bugs, insects and the like) to more “proper” subjects. Most of all, she’s never really felt beautiful or special, which is why she’s driven to continue her masquerade for so long. Her letters to the not-so-fictional Captain MacKenzie gave her the ability to pursue her passions and carve out a life for herself in a world that would have rather placed in her a specific and confining role.
“Sometimes a woman doesn’t quite fit in with her expected role. We do what we can to make our own way, carve out a space for ourselves.”
I loved how Dare developed Maddie’s character, demonstrating that while she may have been odd (who else keeps two pet lobsters named Fluffy and Rex?), she was wonderful just as she was. And, most importantly, Logan comes to love her precisely because of who she is – not who she could be – even while he helps Maddie find the strength to become an even better version of herself. As for Logan….well, he’s not a romance hero for nothing. He maintains an unwavering loyalty to his men, with a steely determination to provide them with a better life. There’s also the fact that he’s an avid reader (!) – which, incidentally, turns out to be a major aphrodisiac for Maddie and *ahem* myself. Sure, he blackmails Maddie at the beginning of the novel in an attempt to get what he wants, but when Dare begins to reveal more of his past and his reaction to Maddie’s letters, it’s not difficult to forgive the man who is only just learning how to find his own dreams and desires.
When a Scot Ties the Knot is delightful, charming and entirely enjoyable – and Maddie is easily one of my favourite Dare heroines, if not the favourite (watch out, Minerva Highwood!). It’s a novel that celebrates women who don’t fit into moulds, soldiers who need someone to help them believe in a life beyond the battlefield, and the kind of love the blooms when you least expect it. This book is an excellent addition to Dare’s body of work and a highly recommended read for romance fans.
I received an advanced copy of this book from Edelweiss in exchange for a fair review.
[Photo Credit: Goodreads]